
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for weddings, groups, and travelers wanting spa + pool + multiple on-site venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a restored-inn style resort in Hampton Bays with historic cottages, a seasonal heated pool, on-site spa and sizable event venues—good for travelers who want a full-service Hamptons retreat that can host weddings and groups. The Roundtree, Amagansett is a high-end Amagansett boutique property with cottage-style rooms and a quiet village location—best for travelers who want a compact, upscale Hamptons stay close to Amagansett Square and nearby beaches.
Updated

Best for weddings, groups, and travelers wanting spa + pool + multiple on-site venues.

Best for a compact, upscale cottage-style stay steps from Amagansett village life and beaches.
When Canoe Place wins: Choose Canoe Place if you want on-site event capacity (large ballroom, pavilion, event lawn), a full-service spa (SommetBeauty), a heated seasonal pool, marina access and a wider range of room and cottage layouts for families or wedding parties.
When The Roundtree wins: Pick The Roundtree for a smaller, higher-rated boutique stay in Amagansett with cottage-style rooms, daily complimentary continental breakfast, free self-parking and easy access to Amagansett Square and nearby beaches.
Bottom line: Canoe Place is the better choice if you need resort amenities, event space and multiple dining outlets; The Roundtree is the pick for a compact luxury stay in the heart of Amagansett where village access and a quieter boutique experience matter most.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | The Roundtree, Amagansett |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored-inn resort with historic cottages, resort amenities and event focus | High-end boutique retreat with cottage-style accommodations |
| Location | Hampton Bays on East Montauk Highway, near Shinnecock Canal and local beaches | 273 Main Street, Amagansett — in Amagansett village, short drive to multiple beaches |
| Size (rooms & cottages) | About 25 accommodations (20 inn suites + 5 standalone cottages, plus a few waterfront residences) | 15 rooms and cottages (supplier listing) |
| Ages / guest policy | All ages welcome; primary guest checking in must be 18+ | All-ages property (not adults-only); primary guest age policy Not published |
| Pool(s) | Heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–October); some waterfront residences have private saltwater pool & hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American, breakfast/lunch/dinner for inn guests), The Study (cocktail lounge), pool-side dining and terrace bar | Complimentary continental breakfast and daily reception; room service (limited hours); no signature on-site restaurant published |
| Spa & wellness | SommetBeauty full-service spa on site with facials, massages, signature Sommet Signature Massage and seasonal hours | Spa services on site (massages available; reservations recommended) |
| Known for | Wedding and event venues (Grand Ballroom, Pavilion, Event/Great Lawn), historic inn site and marina access | Upscale, cottage-style boutique lodging close to Amagansett Square and local beaches |
| Parking & transit | Complimentary self parking, seasonal valet and complimentary train-station transfers (Hampton Bays station) | Free self parking on site; front desk with limited hours |
| Family & pet notes | Family-friendly accommodations, select pet-friendly rooms (dogs up to ~45 lbs, fee; restrictions apply) | Family-friendly listing (pets allowed in specific rooms, surcharges apply); some kid-friendly amenities listed |
Canoe Place sits on East Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays near the Shinnecock Canal with shuttle access to local beaches.
Choose Canoe Place if you want a property with beach shuttle, marina access and easy travel connections for exploring the broader Hamptons.
The Roundtree is located on Main Street in Amagansett, within a short drive of several local beaches and village shops and restaurants.
Pick The Roundtree for a stay right in Amagansett village when you want walkable dining, nightlife and quick beach access.
Canoe Place offers a mix of inn suites and standalone historic cottages plus waterfront residences for groups and families.
Canoe Place gives more variety for groups and families who need multi-bedroom cottages or waterfront residence options.
The Roundtree’s room roster is smaller and focused on cottage-style and barn rooms and suites.
The Roundtree is a compact property with well-appointed rooms and several multi-bedroom cottage/house options for small groups.
Canoe Place runs multiple on-site outlets and pool/terrace dining geared toward guests and private events.
Canoe Place provides more on-site dining variety and the ability to support group meals and private events.
The Roundtree provides daily continental breakfast and a complimentary reception, with limited room service hours.
The Roundtree is ideal if you want a quieter, boutique lodging with included breakfast and evening reception rather than multiple full restaurants on site.
Canoe Place’s signature amenity mix centers on the heated seasonal outdoor pool, marina access and the large event lawn/ballroom.
If a hotel pool plus easy beach transport and on-property marina are priorities, Canoe Place is the stronger match.
The Roundtree focuses on a compact cottage-hotel experience with proximity to Amagansett beaches and village attractions.
Choose The Roundtree if you want to stay in Amagansett village and walk or drive a few minutes to beaches rather than rely on a hotel pool.
Canoe Place pairs an on-site full-service spa with a 24-hour fitness center and an active evening programming in The Study and terrace.
Canoe Place is suited to travelers who want spa treatments, fitness access and some on-site evening programming.
The Roundtree lists on-site spa services and a quiet village setting for evening dining and music nearby.
The Roundtree works well for guests who plan to use a small on-site spa and spend evenings in Amagansett’s village venues.

Canoe Place — large Grand Ballroom, Pavilion and 7,200 sq ft event lawn with multiple venue capacities and event packages.

The Roundtree — small, high-rated boutique property on Main Street close to Amagansett Square and village beaches.

Canoe Place — SommetBeauty spa, 24-hour fitness center, heated seasonal pool and marina access.

The Roundtree — complimentary continental breakfast, daily reception and straightforward access to local shops and beaches.
Canoe Place — it offers a large Grand Ballroom, Pavilion and a sizable event lawn with established wedding packages and capacity for several hundred guests.
The Roundtree — it’s located on 273 Main Street in Amagansett, within minutes of village restaurants, shops and nearby beaches.
Canoe Place publishes a heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–October); The Roundtree’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Canoe Place has an on-site SommetBeauty spa with a full menu of treatments; The Roundtree lists spa services on site but with fewer published details.
No — both properties are listed as all-ages; Canoe Place requires the primary guest checking in to be 18+, and The Roundtree is not adults-only.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·