
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for guests who want a full-service resort experience (spa, seasonal pool, restaurant, and wedding/meeting venues) on the Southampton/Hampton Bays side of the East End.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a restored Hampton Bays resort with historic cottages, a seasonal heated pool, on-site spa and multiple event venues — good for couples, families, and weekend wedding groups. The Chequit is a classic, three-star Shelter Island Heights inn with a coastal, historic feel — read this if you want a small‑town Shelter Island stay with straightforward rooms and an on-site restaurant.
Updated

Best for guests who want a full-service resort experience (spa, seasonal pool, restaurant, and wedding/meeting venues) on the Southampton/Hampton Bays side of the East End.

Best for travelers who want a smaller, traditional Shelter Island inn within easy reach of local attractions and beaches.
When Canoe Place Inn and Cottages wins: pick Canoe Place if you want an on-property spa (SommetBeauty), a heated seasonal pool, a larger set of dining and event spaces, or cottage-style accommodations and waterfront residence options.
When The Chequit wins: choose The Chequit for a compact, historic Shelter Island stay with Tempur‑Pedic beds and a highly rated guest experience in a quiet Heights neighborhood close to Shelter Island Country Club and local beaches.
Bottom line: Canoe Place is the broader, amenity-rich resort choice on the Hampton Bays side of the East End; The Chequit is a smaller, well-rated Shelter Island inn for travelers prioritizing a simpler, classic inn stay and easy island access.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | The Chequit |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored 17th-century inn site reimagined as a full-service Hampton Bays resort with cottages and event spaces. | Historic Shelter Island inn with a classic coastal getaway feel. |
| Location | Hampton Bays (Shinnecock Canal), near local beaches and town amenities. | Shelter Island Heights (The Heights), near Shelter Island Country Club and local beaches. |
| Size / rooms | Main inn: ~20 suites + 5 standalone cottages + small waterfront residences (sources vary on totals). | 35 guestrooms. |
| Stars / guest rating | 4-star (as marketed) · multiple guest-review sources; high-end resort positioning. | 3-star · guest rating 9.2 (per supplier listing). |
| Pool | Heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–Oct); separate waterfront residences may have private saltwater pool/hot tub. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American) + The Study cocktail lounge + pool/terrace bars. | On-site restaurant + coffee shop/cafe (one each). |
| Spa & wellness | SommetBeauty full-service spa (facials, massages, body treatments) + 24-hour fitness center. | Not published |
| Accessibility & family policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 18+ to check in; some accessible suites and one single-level accessible cottage. | AdultsOnly: false; property open to families (no published adults-only policy). |
| Parking & transport | Complimentary self parking, seasonal valet, free train-station transfers and beach shuttle. | Free self parking; front desk limited hours; distances to local sites listed. |
| Known for | Weddings, large events, restored historic property with resort amenities. | Classic Shelter Island inn atmosphere and strong guest ratings. |
Canoe Place sits on East Montauk Highway between the Atlantic and Shinnecock Bay in Hampton Bays, with beach shuttle service.
Choose Canoe Place for easy mainland access to multiple beaches, train connections and day-trip options across the Hamptons.
The Chequit is located on Grand Ave in Shelter Island Heights, placing guests near island attractions and beaches.
Choose The Chequit if you want to be based on Shelter Island for quieter island exploration and local sights.
Canoe Place offers a mix of inn suites, standalone historic cottages and a small collection of waterfront residences.
Canoe Place is better when you want cottage-style privacy or suites for families and groups.
The Chequit provides a smaller, simpler room inventory with a handful of upgraded suite options.
The Chequit is a straightforward inn with defined room categories and a consistent, classic guestroom offering.
Canoe Place has on-site dining geared to seasonal East End produce and a dedicated cocktail lounge.
Canoe Place offers more on-property dining variety and schedule for guests who prefer to eat and drink without leaving the resort.
The Chequit has an on-site restaurant plus a coffee shop/cafe for casual snacks and drinks.
The Chequit covers basic on-property meals and quick coffee options but expects guests to explore off-site dining for more variety.
Canoe Place runs a heated outdoor seasonal pool and provides beach shuttle service and beach amenities.
If pool time or easy beach runs matter, Canoe Place has clear on-property and shuttle beach amenities.
The Chequit listing does not publish an on-site pool; it lists proximity to nearby beaches such as Sunset Beach and Crescent Beach.
Expect to visit local beaches rather than use an on-site pool when staying at The Chequit.
Canoe Place includes an on-site SommetBeauty spa plus a 24-hour fitness center and evening lounge programming.
Canoe Place is stronger for spa and fitness-focused stays plus casual evening lounge programming.
The Chequit listing shows limited front desk hours and basic property services; no spa or formal wellness program is published.
The Chequit is better suited to guests who plan their own wellness activities around Shelter Island rather than relying on on-site spa services.

Canoe Place — on-site SommetBeauty spa and a heated seasonal pool plus poolside dining and loungers.

The Chequit — a compact, historic Shelter Island inn with well-rated guestrooms and a simple on-property restaurant.

Canoe Place — multiple large venues (Grand Ballroom, Pavilion, Great Lawn) and event capacities for sizable weddings and meetings.

The Chequit — Shelter Island location and a smaller-property footprint suit travelers wanting a quieter island base.
Canoe Place is explicitly set up for families with cottages and family-friendly amenities plus pool and beach shuttle; both properties allow children, but Canoe Place lists more family services.
The Chequit's supplier listing does not publish a spa or an on-site pool. Canoe Place publishes both a full-service spa and a heated seasonal pool.
Canoe Place — it offers multiple large event venues, a Grand Ballroom, Pavilion and lawn settings with published capacities and wedding packages.
Neither property is published as adults-only overall. Canoe Place requires the primary guest checking in to be 18+, and a day‑pass listing describes a poolside day-pass as adults-only; The Chequit is not adults-only.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·