
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for couples and families who want a Hamptons-style resort with cottages, seasonal pool days, and an on-site spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a restored historic inn and cottage resort in Hampton Bays with a seasonal pool, full-service SommetBeauty spa, and on-site dining for travelers wanting a coastal Hamptons experience. The Preston House & Hotel is a highly rated boutique hotel in downtown Riverhead for travelers who prefer a polished, walkable small-city stay near North Fork day trips and regional attractions.
Updated

Best for couples and families who want a Hamptons-style resort with cottages, seasonal pool days, and an on-site spa.

Best for travelers who want a compact, polished boutique stay in Riverhead with easy access to restaurants, theaters, and day trips to the North Fork.
When Canoe Place Inn and Cottages wins: choose Canoe Place if you prioritize a Hamptons resort vibe — standalone cottages, a heated seasonal outdoor pool, beach shuttle and an on-site full-service spa (SommetBeauty). It’s also the clearer pick for wedding and event stays because of large ballroom and lawn venues.
When The Preston House & Hotel wins: pick The Preston House for a downtown Riverhead location, a small upscale boutique hotel feel, high guest ratings, and easy access to local attractions (theaters, vineyards, outlet shopping and ferries to nearby areas).
Bottom line: Canoe Place is the Hamptons resort option with cottages, pools, beach access and spa programming; The Preston House & Hotel is a compact, highly rated downtown alternative for guests who want convenience and a polished independent-hotel experience outside the Hamptons core.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | The Preston House & Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort-style Hamptons property with historic cottages, marina and event lawns. | Polished boutique hotel in historic downtown Riverhead. |
| Location | Hampton Bays, between the Atlantic and Shinnecock Bay; beach shuttle provided. | 428 E Main Street, Riverhead — walkable to downtown attractions and venues. |
| Size / rooms | Main inn suites plus standalone cottages and a small collection of waterfront residences (sources list ~25 units total across inn & cottages). | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 18+ to check in. | All ages welcome; adultsOnly: false (primary guest minimum age per listing is 21 to check in). |
| Pools & water access | Heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–October); some waterfront residences have private saltwater pool & hot tub; complimentary beach shuttle and beach gear for guests. | Access to nearby indoor and outdoor pools is listed; not a beachfront resort. |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American) and The Study cocktail lounge; pool menu and terrace bar available. | Not published |
| Wellness & fitness | SommetBeauty full-service spa (facials, massages, body treatments) and a 24-hour fitness center. | Fitness facilities and 24-hour fitness center listed; no on-site spa published in supplier listing. |
| Event & meeting space | Large wedding and event facilities (Grand Ballroom 5,087 sq ft, Pavilion, Great Lawn) and multiple meeting rooms. | Conference center and one meeting room; suitable for smaller business or group needs. |
| Transport & parking | Complimentary self parking, seasonal valet, complimentary Hampton Bays train-station transfers. | Free self parking and uncovered parking; 24-hour front desk and concierge services. |
| Key nearby attractions | Local beaches (Ponquogue, Meschutt), Shinnecock Hills & area golf courses, Hampton Bays train station. | Suffolk Theater, Splish Splash Water Park, wineries and Tanger Outlets within driving distance. |
Canoe Place sits in Hampton Bays along the Shinnecock Canal with beach access and a complimentary beach shuttle.
Choose Canoe Place for beach access and a coastal Hamptons setting with easy transport options to nearby beaches.
The Preston House & Hotel is located at 428 E Main Street in downtown Riverhead within walking distance of restaurants and venues.
Choose The Preston House if you want a walkable downtown stay with easy access to local attractions and services.
Canoe Place offers a mix of inn suites and standalone cottages plus a few waterfront residences for variety and privacy.
Canoe Place gives more options for families or groups seeking cottage-style privacy and multi-bedroom stays.
The Preston House provides a compact set of boutique rooms and suites oriented to a downtown boutique-hotel guest.
The Preston House focuses on polished, comfortable rooms for travelers who value downtown access over resort-style accommodations.
Canoe Place centers on Good Ground Tavern and The Study for on-site dining and cocktails.
Canoe Place gives an on-site seasonal restaurant and a fireside cocktail lounge; good for resort-style dining without leaving property.
The Preston House listing shows food and beverage conveniences like a bar and nearby dining options in downtown Riverhead.
The Preston House is best for guests who want quick access to a range of independent downtown eateries and an included breakfast.
Canoe Place is a resort with a heated seasonal outdoor pool and beach support services.
If swimming, private waterfront residence access or easy beach logistics matter, Canoe Place is the stronger choice.
The Preston House lists access to nearby indoor and outdoor pools rather than an on-site resort pool.
The Preston House is not a beach resort; expect to travel for full beach days or large resort-style pool facilities.
Canoe Place operates SommetBeauty spa and a 24-hour fitness center on property.
Canoe Place is the better pick if on-site spa treatments and resort leisure programming are priorities.
The Preston House emphasizes concierge service, fitness access and downtown nightlife choices.
Choose The Preston House for walkable nightlife and concierge-arranged local experiences rather than an on-site spa focus.

Canoe Place — heated seasonal pool, beach shuttle, chairs and towels plus nearby Hampton Bays beaches.

The Preston House — central Riverhead location within walking distance of theaters, restaurants and local services.

Canoe Place — large Grand Ballroom, Pavilion and Great Lawn with detailed wedding packages and capacities.

The Preston House — highly rated boutique hotel rooms and city-adjacent access for day trips and shopping.
Canoe Place is more family-friendly for beach days, pool time and multi-bedroom cottages; both properties welcome children but Canoe Place’s cottages and family amenities give more options.
Book Canoe Place for on-site SommetBeauty spa services; The Preston House does not publish an on-site spa in its supplier listing.
The Preston House is preferable for walkable downtown dining and evening entertainment in Riverhead; Canoe Place offers on-site dining and seasonal evening programming but is more resort-focused.
Neither property is published as adults-only for overall stays. Canoe Place requires the primary guest to be 18+ to check in; The Preston House’s supplier listing shows a minimum check-in age of 21.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·