
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for families and event groups who want a Hamptons resort with cottages, on-site spa, and multiple meeting/wedding venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a restored 17th‑century Hamptons boutique resort with historic cottages, a full-service SommetBeauty spa, seasonal pool, and on-site dining — read this if you want a family-friendly East End resort with event spaces. Oyster Estate is an upscale Greenport boutique property with a luxury‑home atmosphere — read this if you want a compact, highly rated North Fork base for exploring Greenport and nearby wineries.
Updated

Best for families and event groups who want a Hamptons resort with cottages, on-site spa, and multiple meeting/wedding venues.

Best for travelers who want a small, highly rated boutique stay inside Greenport with easy walking access to village attractions.
When Canoe Place Inn and Cottages wins: pick Canoe Place if you want more on-site amenities (full spa, heated seasonal pool, marina, larger event/wedding spaces) and options for standalone cottages or waterfront residences that suit families or groups.
When Oyster Estate wins: pick Oyster Estate if you prefer a compact boutique hotel in the heart of Greenport with higher guest ratings, easy access to village shops, museums, and a quieter North Fork base for winery visits.
Bottom line: both are 4‑star East End boutique properties; choose Canoe Place for a full‑service Hamptons resort experience and event capacity, and choose Oyster Estate for a polished, small‑scale Greenport stay.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | Oyster Estate |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic waterfront resort with resort amenities and event spaces | Upscale Greenport boutique property with a luxury‑home atmosphere |
| Location | Hampton Bays (Shinnecock Canal) — beach shuttle to local beaches | 326 Front St, Greenport — central to Greenport village attractions |
| Size / rooms | 20 suites in the main inn + 5 standalone cottages; small inventory of waterfront residences | 34 air‑conditioned rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 18+ to check in | All ages welcome (not adults‑only) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–Oct); some waterfront residences have private saltwater pool & hot tub | Outdoor seasonal pool and 1 hot tub listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American) + The Study cocktail lounge; pool menu and terrace/pool bar | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | SommetBeauty full‑service spa (facials, massages, body treatments) and 24‑hour fitness center | Health or beauty spa nearby (supplier listing) |
| Meetings & events | Large event capacity (Grand Ballroom 5,087 sq ft; Pavilion; Event Lawn) and multiple meeting rooms | Conference space ~275 sq ft and 2 meeting rooms |
| Transport & parking | Complimentary self parking and seasonal valet; complimentary Hampton Bays train pickup | Uncovered/limited parking; free self parking listed |
| Known for | Weddings, waterfront cottages, full resort programming | Central Greenport location and high guest rating |
Canoe Place sits on East Montauk Highway along the Shinnecock Canal, between the Atlantic and Shinnecock Bay.
Best if you want easy beach access and a Hamptons‑style waterfront base.
Oyster Estate is located on Front Street in central Greenport within easy walking distance of village sights.
Best if you want a walkable Greenport location for shops, museums, and harbor activities.
Canoe Place offers a mixture of inn suites, standalone historic cottages, and a small number of waterfront residences.
Choose Canoe Place for flexible room configurations or private cottage/residence options for families or groups.
Oyster Estate lists 34 air‑conditioned rooms with a mix of classic and signature room types.
Choose Oyster Estate if you want consistent room offerings in a compact boutique building.
Canoe Place has an on‑site seasonal restaurant and several casual bar/terrace options.
Pick Canoe Place if you want on‑site dining and poolside service without leaving the property.
Oyster Estate’s supplier listing emphasizes comfort in‑room features; on‑site signature restaurants aren’t specified.
Pick Oyster Estate if you plan to dine in Greenport’s village restaurants rather than relying on hotel dining.
Canoe Place operates a heated outdoor seasonal pool and offers additional private pools for some residences.
Canoe Place is stronger when pool access and waterside amenities matter.
Oyster Estate lists an outdoor seasonal pool and one hot tub among its amenities.
Oyster Estate offers a small seasonal pool as a guest amenity but not the larger resort pool program Canoe Place runs.
Canoe Place emphasizes a full‑service spa alongside 24‑hour fitness and evening lounges.
Choose Canoe Place if an on‑site spa and more evening programming are priorities.
Oyster Estate is described as an upscale boutique stay; a nearby health/beauty spa is listed.
Oyster Estate is a good fit if you want a quiet boutique stay and plan to use nearby Greenport wellness or activity providers.

Canoe Place — Grand Ballroom, Pavilion, Event Lawn and multiple meeting spaces with high capacities.

Oyster Estate — front‑street location puts museums, the carousel, and village dining within a short walk.

Canoe Place — SommetBeauty spa, 24‑hour fitness center, pool programming, and curated evening events.

Oyster Estate — high guest rating (9.2) and a refined small‑hotel feel in the North Fork.
Canoe Place is more family‑oriented with cottages, beach shuttle service, and broader on‑site amenities; both properties allow guests of all ages, but Canoe Place offers more family‑friendly programming.
Oyster Estate — it’s on Front Street in central Greenport within easy walking distance of village dining and attractions.
Both list seasonal outdoor pools; Canoe Place operates an on‑site full‑service SommetBeauty spa, while Oyster Estate’s listing notes a health/beauty spa nearby rather than naming an on‑site full spa.
Canoe Place — it has large ballroom and lawn venues and extensive meeting/wedding capacities; Oyster Estate has smaller conference space suitable for compact meetings.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·