
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for travelers who want a full-service Hamptons inn with an on-site spa, seasonally heated pool, and multiple event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a restored historic inn and cottage collection in Hampton Bays with full-service amenities (pool, on-site spa, Good Ground Tavern)—read this if you want a history-forward, full-service Hampton Bays stay. The Bentley Hotel Southampton is a budget boutique–style, 2‑star Southampton-area hotel with strong guest ratings—read this if you want a value-minded Southampton base close to beaches and golf.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a full-service Hamptons inn with an on-site spa, seasonally heated pool, and multiple event spaces.

Best for travelers seeking affordable, well-rated Southampton-area rooms with basic kitchenette conveniences and easy access to nearby beaches and golf.
When Canoe Place Inn and Cottages wins: choose Canoe Place if you prioritize a heated seasonal pool, an on-site full-service spa (SommetBeauty), a lively on-property restaurant (Good Ground Tavern), and event/wedding facilities—plus cottage-style privacy options.
When The Bentley Hotel Southampton wins: pick The Bentley if you want lower-star, value-oriented lodging in the Southampton area with private beach access nearby, kitchenettes in rooms, free self parking, and a high guest rating for basics and location.
Bottom line: Canoe Place is the fuller-service, historic Hamptons property with spa and wedding/event facilities; The Bentley is a budget boutique alternative in Southampton that covers essentials well and can save money for travelers who don’t need full resort services.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | The Bentley Hotel Southampton |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic 17th-century inn reimagined as a full-service Hampton Bays retreat | Budget boutique–style motel/hotel with Art Deco touches and practical guestrooms |
| Location | Hampton Bays, on East Montauk Highway near Shinnecock Canal and local beaches | Southampton (161 Hills Station Rd), a short drive to The Hamptons beaches and several golf courses |
| Size / rooms | About 25 lodging units (20 inn suites + 5 standalone historic cottages; small waterfront residence collection also available) | 40 individually furnished guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; main guest must be 18+ to check in (property markets family-friendly amenities) | All ages welcome; property is not adults-only |
| Pools & beach access | Heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–Oct); some waterfront residences have separate private saltwater pool/hot tub; complimentary beach shuttle and beach amenities | Seasonal outdoor pool; private beach nearby and water activities listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American; breakfast/lunch/dinner hours vary) and The Study cocktail lounge | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | SommetBeauty full-service spa on site (facials, massages, body treatments; Mon–Sat 10–6, Sun 10–2) plus 24-hour fitness center | Use of nearby fitness center (discount); no on-site full-service spa published |
| Known for | Historic property, weddings/events (ballroom, pavilion, large lawns), spa, pool and marina access | Value-minded Southampton-area lodging with kitchenettes, private beach access, and high guest ratings |
| Parking & transport | Complimentary self parking and seasonal valet; free train station pickups and beach shuttle | Free self parking on site; near local airports and beaches |
| Accessibility | Accessible suites via elevator and one single-level restored cottage; step-free options noted | Wheelchair-accessible registration desk, accessible parking, wheelchair-accessible path of travel and pool hoist on site; some upper floors accessible by stairs only |
Canoe Place sits on East Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays near the Shinnecock Canal and several local beaches.
Choose Canoe Place for easier direct access to Hampton Bays beaches, marinas, and local amenities.
The Bentley Hotel is in Southampton with straightforward driving access to local beaches and golf courses.
Choose The Bentley for a Southampton-area base convenient to beaches and golf without resort-scale grounds.
Canoe Place mixes inn suites and standalone historic cottages, plus a small waterfront residence collection.
Canoe Place suits travelers who want a variety of room styles including private cottages and waterfront residences.
The Bentley offers individually furnished guestrooms and suites, many with kitchenettes and private balconies/patios.
The Bentley is practical for travelers who want kitchenette conveniences and larger TVs at a lower star rating.
Canoe Place has on-site full-service dining and a cocktail lounge.
If on-property dining and evening cocktails matter, Canoe Place offers a fuller food-and-drink experience.
The Bentley’s listing emphasizes in-room kitchenettes and basic on-property amenities rather than multiple restaurants.
The Bentley suits travelers who plan to eat off-property or use the kitchenette for light meals.
Canoe Place features a heated outdoor seasonal pool and beachfront amenities via shuttle.
Canoe Place is better if you want a full pool program plus beach shuttle and waterfront options.
The Bentley offers a seasonal outdoor pool and access to a private beach nearby.
The Bentley provides simple pool facilities and nearby private beach access for active beach/go-to-beach travelers.
Canoe Place provides a full-service spa, fitness center, and sizable event spaces.
Pick Canoe Place if spa services, on-site fitness, or event-capable venues are priorities.
The Bentley focuses on practical guest services and local activity access rather than a dedicated spa or event complex.
The Bentley is suitable for travelers who want a simple base and plan to use local spas or venues off site.

Canoe Place — on-site SommetBeauty spa plus 24-hour fitness center and wellness treatments.

Canoe Place — standalone historic cottages and waterfront residences for families or small groups.

The Bentley — lower-star, well-rated hotel with kitchenettes and simple on-property amenities.

The Bentley — close driving distance to several Hamptons beaches and local golf courses like Sebonack and Shinnecock Hills.
Canoe Place has an on-site full-service SommetBeauty spa; The Bentley does not publish a full-service spa on the property.
Neither property is a full-property adults-only hotel. Canoe Place requires the primary guest checking in to be at least 18; a day-pass product has been marketed as adults-only but that applies to certain pool day-pass experiences rather than overall admission.
Canoe Place is more suited to families or groups needing multiple-bedroom cottages or event spaces; The Bentley offers practical one‑bedroom suites and kitchenettes but fewer large-group amenities.
The Bentley lists kitchenettes with refrigerators and microwaves in many rooms; Canoe Place provides cottages and residences with fuller kitchen or cottage layouts in select accommodations.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·