
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for classic Hamptons stays, weddings, and guests who want an on-site full-service spa and standalone cottages.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a restored historic Hampton Bays boutique resort with cottages, a full-service spa and seasonal heated pool—good for couples, families and wedding groups who want a Hamptons headland experience. Hotel Indigo Long Island East End is a branded lifestyle IHG hotel in Riverhead with meeting space, a seasonal pool and on-site bistro—good for shoppers, conference attendees and travelers using Riverhead as an East End gateway.
Updated

Best for classic Hamptons stays, weddings, and guests who want an on-site full-service spa and standalone cottages.

Best for travelers who want a recognizable hotel brand with meeting space, a pool, and easy access to Riverhead shopping and family attractions.
When Canoe Place Inn and Cottages wins: choose Canoe Place for a small-property, historic-Hamptons vibe, on-site SommetBeauty spa services, private cottages and a seasonal heated pool with complimentary beach shuttle—ideal for romantic getaways, spa breaks, and weddings.
When Hotel Indigo Long Island East End wins: choose Hotel Indigo for a larger, full-service branded hotel that supports meetings and events, has more conventional hotel conveniences (business center, EV charging, complimentary shuttle within 5 miles) and is a practical base for North Fork wineries, Tanger Outlets and family attractions like Splish Splash Water Park.
Bottom line: both work for East End trips—pick Canoe Place for boutique, spa and cottage-driven Hamptons experiences; pick Hotel Indigo for branded convenience, larger meeting spaces and proximity to Riverhead services and attractions.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | Hotel Indigo Long Island East End |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic boutique resort with cottages, fireplaces and a small‑property feel | Branded lifestyle hotel with contemporary public spaces and conference facilities |
| Location | Hampton Bays between Shinnecock Bay and the Atlantic; beach shuttle to local beaches | Riverhead, connected to a shopping center and near family attractions and outlets |
| Size | About 20 suites in the main inn plus 5 standalone cottages and a small number of waterfront residences | 96 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 18+ to check in | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools | Heated outdoor seasonal pool (May–October); waterfront residences may have private pools/hot tubs | Outdoor seasonal pool (seasonal; listed dates published by hotel) |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American) and The Study cocktail lounge; pool menu and terrace dining | Bistro 72 poolside bistro and bar; room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | SommetBeauty full-service spa with facials, massages and signature Sommet treatments | Wheelchair-accessible spa listed in facilities (full-service details not published) |
| Known for | Historic property, wedding venues (Grand Ballroom, Pavilion, Event Lawn) and cottages | Riverhead gateway hotel with meeting rooms, conference space and free area shuttle |
| Meetings & events | Large ballroom and multiple event lawns — Grand Ballroom 5,087 sq ft; large outdoor event lawn | About 5,538 sq ft (514 m²) of conference space across 4 meeting rooms |
| Transport & access | Complimentary train-station transfers (Hampton Bays), complimentary beach shuttle, free parking | Connected to a shopping center, free self parking, free area shuttle within 5 miles and preferred airport ISP |
Canoe Place sits in Hampton Bays beside the Shinnecock Canal with easy access to local beaches and coastal activities.
Choose Canoe Place if you want a coastal Hamptons base and quick beach access.
Hotel Indigo is in Riverhead, serving as a practical East End gateway near outlets and family attractions.
Choose Hotel Indigo if you want Riverhead convenience, shopping and family-friendly day trips.
Canoe Place offers a mix of inn suites and standalone historic cottages and a few waterfront residences.
Canoe Place is for guests who want private cottage layouts or historic suite character.
Hotel Indigo’s inventory is conventional hotel-style rooms and suites across 96 guestrooms.
Hotel Indigo fits travelers who prefer predictable branded rooms and a larger room selection.
Canoe Place’s on-site dining centers on Good Ground Tavern and The Study lounge.
Canoe Place focuses on seasonal, locally-sourced East End cuisine in a boutique setting.
Hotel Indigo’s dining option is Bistro 72, a poolside bistro offering American cuisine and a bar.
Hotel Indigo offers convenient poolside dining and the expectations of a branded hotel restaurant.
Canoe Place’s signature leisure features are its seasonal heated pool and private cottage/residence amenities.
Canoe Place suits guests seeking a boutique pool experience and optional private-residence pools.
Hotel Indigo offers a seasonal outdoor pool and poolside dining at Bistro 72.
Hotel Indigo provides a classic hotel pool plus poolside dining—good for families and day trips.
Canoe Place emphasizes spa services, intimate evening programming and large wedding/event facilities.
Canoe Place works well for spa-focused stays, fireside cocktails and wedding weekends.
Hotel Indigo has fitness and business facilities plus evening entertainment and event spaces.
Hotel Indigo is aimed at guests who need meeting infrastructure and conventional hotel services.

Canoe Place — SommetBeauty full-service spa and a boutique, low‑scale property with cottage options.

Hotel Indigo — larger branded meeting infrastructure and a business center with 4 meeting rooms.

Canoe Place — complimentary beach shuttle, beach chairs/towels and close Hamptons beaches.

Hotel Indigo — connected to shopping, near family attractions and shuttle service within 5 miles.
Canoe Place is built for weddings with a 5,087 sq ft Grand Ballroom, Pavilion and a 7,200 sq ft Event Lawn; Hotel Indigo has conference space (about 5,538 sq ft) suited to meetings but Canoe Place has more dedicated wedding venues.
Canoe Place has an on-site full-service SommetBeauty spa with published hours and signature treatments. Hotel Indigo lists a wheelchair-accessible spa in its facilities, but full spa-service details are not published in the supplied listing.
Canoe Place provides a complimentary beach shuttle, beach chairs/towels and closer access to Hampton Bays beaches. Hotel Indigo is in Riverhead and requires a drive to Atlantic beaches.
Yes. Canoe Place welcomes guests of all ages (primary guest must be 18+); Hotel Indigo is not adults-only and lists family-oriented nearby attractions.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·