
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages
Best for families and small groups who want waterfront cottages, a seasonal pool and an on‑site full-service spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Canoe Place Inn and Cottages is a reimagined historic Shinnecock Canal retreat in Hampton Bays with cottages, a seasonal heated pool and an on-site spa; read this if you want a waterfront, family-friendly Hamptons base with event spaces. The Maidstone is an established boutique hotel in East Hampton village; read this if you prefer a small, walkable village stay near shops, galleries and beaches.
Updated

Best for families and small groups who want waterfront cottages, a seasonal pool and an on‑site full-service spa.

Best for visitors who want a compact East Hampton village stay within easy reach of Main Street shops, galleries and nearby beaches.
When Canoe Place Inn and Cottages wins: choose Canoe Place for a property with more substantial event and meeting space, standalone cottages or waterfront residences, a full-service spa (SommetBeauty), and a heated seasonal outdoor pool for summer stays.
When The Maidstone wins: choose The Maidstone if you want to be in the heart of East Hampton village with easy walking access to Main Street, local restaurants and cultural sites and a small, established boutique-hotel feel.
Bottom line: Canoe Place is the broader resort-style option for guests prioritizing pools, spa and cottages on the canal; The Maidstone is the compact village alternative for travelers who want to be steps from East Hampton’s Main Street.
| Category | Canoe Place Inn and Cottages | The Maidstone |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Reimagined historic inn and cottage resort on the Shinnecock Canal | Established boutique hotel set in East Hampton village |
| Location | Hampton Bays, set between Shinnecock Bay and the Atlantic | 207 Main Street, East Hampton village |
| Size / rooms | Main inn suites plus standalone cottages and a small waterfront residence collection (room-type list of 13 types) | 19 air-conditioned rooms and a mix of suites and cottages (room types listed) |
| Adults-only policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 18+ to check in | |
| Pools | Heated seasonal outdoor pool (May–October); some waterfront residences have private saltwater pool/hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Good Ground Tavern (seasonal American) and The Study cocktail lounge; pool-side menu and terrace/pool bar | LDV restaurant on-site; bar/lounge and complimentary continental breakfast |
| Spa & wellness | SommetBeauty full-service spa (facials, massages, body treatments) and a 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Historic-site conversion with cottages, marina access and wedding/event venues (Grand Ballroom, Great Lawn) | Village setting near Mulford Farm, Guild Hall and East Hampton beaches |
| Beach access | Complimentary beach shuttle, chairs/towels/umbrellas and beach transfers to local Hampton Bays beaches | |
| Parking & transport | Complimentary self parking, seasonal valet and free train-station pickup (Hampton Bays) | Free self parking and front desk limited hours; near East Hampton transport links |
Canoe Place sits along the Shinnecock Canal in Hampton Bays, between the bay and the Atlantic.
Canoe Place is a waterfront resort location geared to beach and boating days rather than village strolling.
The Maidstone is on Main Street in East Hampton, within walking distance of shops, galleries and cultural sites.
The Maidstone puts you in the middle of East Hampton village life and short walks to local attractions.
Canoe Place offers a mix of inn suites and standalone cottages plus a limited collection of waterfront residences.
Choose Canoe Place for more room-type variety and private cottage options.
The Maidstone provides 19 air-conditioned rooms and a selection of suites and cottages appropriate for a boutique village hotel.
The Maidstone is a compact, intimate option if you want a village hotel rather than a resort compound.
Canoe Place centers its food and drink around Good Ground Tavern and The Study cocktail lounge.
Dining at Canoe Place focuses on seasonal, locally-sourced menus and resort-style pool/terrace service.
The Maidstone has LDV as its on-site dining option and a bar/lounge for evening drinks.
The Maidstone is convenient for village dining: an on-site restaurant plus many nearby choices on Main Street.
Canoe Place runs a heated seasonal outdoor pool and supports beach days with shuttle service and beach gear.
Pick Canoe Place for on-site pool options and full beach support for summer stays.
The Maidstone focuses on village location and offers guest transport to nearby beaches.
The Maidstone is better for guests prioritizing village access; pool facilities are not published.
Canoe Place includes a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness center plus evening cocktails in The Study.
Canoe Place is the choice for in-house spa treatments and a modest on-property evening scene.
The Maidstone’s supplier listing highlights nearby cultural spots and a small on-site bar/lounge.
Choose The Maidstone for village nightlife and walking access to galleries; for in-house spa services, Canoe Place is clearer.

Canoe Place — SommetBeauty on site plus a 24-hour fitness center and spa treatment menu.

The Maidstone — set on East Hampton’s Main Street within easy walking distance of shops, Guild Hall and local galleries.

Canoe Place — standalone cottages and a small waterfront residence collection that suit families and groups.

The Maidstone — a small, established hotel ideal for short stays focused on village amenities.
Canoe Place is more family-friendly with multi-bedroom cottages, pool access and beach shuttle services; both properties welcome children but the primary check-in guest must be 18+.
The Maidstone is in East Hampton village on Main Street; Canoe Place is in Hampton Bays and not within walking distance of East Hampton’s Main Street.
Canoe Place lists a full-service SommetBeauty spa and a 24-hour fitness center; The Maidstone’s listing does not publish a spa or fitness center.
Canoe Place offers Good Ground Tavern and a cocktail lounge plus pool-side dining; The Maidstone has LDV on site and the advantage of many village restaurants steps away.
Explore how Canoe Place Inn and Cottages stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·